5-inch K-style aluminum
The standard — fits most Long Island homes. $7-$10/lf installed.
Full tear-off, fascia repair, new system
Gutter Replacement Across Long Island
Old gutters sagging, leaking, pulling away from the house? Full replacement includes tear-off, fascia inspection and repairs, new apron flashing, new drip edge, and brand-new seamless aluminum — hung the way it should have been the first time.
4.9 · 214 Google reviews
Licensed & $2M General Liability
LeafFilter Certified Installer
Family-owned since 2014
Most gutter replacement calls we get come from one of three problems: chronic leaks at seams (sectional gutters reaching end of life), pulling away from the fascia (spike hangers failed), or visible sag and overflow (undersized or pitched wrong).
Full replacement is not the same as re-hanging. We tear off the old runs completely, inspect every fascia board, replace rotted sections, install new apron flashing and drip edge, and then hang brand-new seamless aluminum with hidden hangers every 24 inches.
The typical Long Island colonial runs $1,800-$3,200 for a full aluminum replacement. Copper, steel, or homes with heavy fascia rot run higher — but everything is itemized on the quote before we start.
What’s included
Here’s exactly what we do on every gutter replacement job.
Full tear-off of existing gutters
Disposal included. Magnet sweep of driveway and landscaping before we leave.
Fascia board inspection
Every board, every run. Rot gets shown to you and repaired at transparent time-and-materials pricing.
New aluminum apron flashing
Tucked under shingles, over gutter lip. Stops wind-driven rain from getting behind gutters.
New drip edge if missing
Catches roof runoff cleanly. Required by code on new roofs but often missing on older homes.
Seamless aluminum 5" or 6"
Formed on your driveway. Continuous runs, heavy-gauge .032 coil, 27 color options.
Hidden hangers every 24"
Stainless screws into solid wood. Never pulls out, never shows from the ground.
Oversize 3x4 downspouts
~50% more capacity than standard 2x3. Eliminates overflow on big roof sheds.
Flow test + before/after photos
We hose-test every run before we leave. Photos texted same day.
Lifetime workmanship warranty
If our install fails — a leak, a sag, a fallen hanger — we come back at no charge for as long as you own the home.
Our process
Four steps, written on the quote.
1
Site visit & quote
On-site measurement, roof walk, fascia inspection. Written quote the same day — no 'I'll email it later.'
2
Schedule + color selection
Once approved, we lock a date (typically within 7 days) and you pick from our 27 stock colors.
3
Tear-off & fascia work
Morning: old gutters come down, fascia gets inspected, any rot gets repaired. Photos sent mid-morning.
4
Install, flash, test, cleanup
Afternoon: new gutters formed, hung, flashed, downspouts run, flow test, full cleanup with magnet sweep.
Materials & options
Here’s the honest rundown of your options.
6-inch K-style aluminum
Recommended for steep roofs, long runs, or heavy tree cover. $9-$12/lf.
Steel gutters
Heavier, stiffer, for commercial or large homes. $9-$14/lf.
Real jobs
A few recent gutter replacement jobs across Long Island.
Check-ins near you
gutter replacementjobs we’ve finished recently.
Levittown·2026-03-18
Gutter Replacement
Tore off 40-year-old steel gutters, wrapped fascia with white aluminum coil, installed 160ft of new 5-inch seamless. Fixed pitch that was causing overflow by the front door.
Hauppauge·2026-02-24
Gutter Replacement
Replaced ice-dam-damaged back gutter and added heat cable to the low-pitch porch roof. Repitched the remaining runs for proper drainage.
Hicksville·2025-12-15
Gutter Replacement
Fascia had water damage under old gutters. Replaced 18ft of rotted fascia board, wrapped with aluminum coil, installed new seamless 5-inch.
East Meadow·2025-09-15
Gutter Replacement
Full system replacement on a cape. Old vinyl gutters had cracked at every joint. Replaced with white aluminum seamless, 5-inch, 3x4 downspouts.
4.9· 214 Google reviews
What homeowners say after we finish.
“Danny's crew installed seamless gutters on our colonial. Formed on-site — no seams anywhere. 2 years later, zero leaks.”
“Ice dam tore down our back gutter in January. Kyle replaced the run, fixed the pitch, installed heat cable. Problem hasn't come back.”
“Got three quotes for gutter guards. LI Gutter was the only one that didn't try to upsell me to LeafFilter at 3x the price.”
Common questions
Before you schedule, here’s what homeowners ask.
Still wondering about something? Call (516) 529-6634and we’ll walk you through it.
(516) 529-6634Rule of thumb: if more than 30% of your runs show seam leaks, sag, or detached sections, full replacement is cheaper over 10 years than chasing repairs. We'll give you an honest read during the free estimate — sometimes a repair is the right call and we'll say so.
Usually not worth it. New downspouts come pre-painted to match, and on a full replacement it doesn't make sense to tie old 2x3 pipes into a new 3x4 system. But if your downspouts are recent (5 years or newer), we can reuse them and discount the job.
Covered above: every board inspected, rot shown to you, repaired at time-and-materials. Typical fascia replacement is $60-$120 per 16-foot board. If your fascia is entirely gone, we'll recommend a capentry contact before we hang new gutters.
Usually no painting needed — we match to your trim color from our 27 stock options. If you need a truly custom color, we can order a custom aluminum coil run (2-3 week lead time, small surcharge).
Gutter replacement rarely requires a permit in Nassau or Suffolk — it's considered like-for-like maintenance. If we're doing major fascia repair or attached structural work, we'll tell you and pull the permit.
Most first-quote visits turn into scheduled jobs within 7-10 days. Spring and fall are our busiest seasons — if you can flex, mid-summer and mid-winter often have faster openings.
Related services
Free quote in one visit
Ready for a real quote on your gutters?
Pick up the phone or send us the details. We'll respond same-day, Monday through Saturday.
- Free, no-pressure written estimate
- Licensed, insured, family-run since 2014
- Seamless gutters formed on your driveway
- Same crew from measure to cleanup
(516) 529-6634
Mon-Sat, 7am to 5pm