Gutter Repair
Leak at the front corner miter after an ice dam. Cut out the bad section, formed a new corner on-site, sealed and re-hung. In and out in 2 hours.
Gutter services in Bay Shore
Bay Shore straddles three worlds — the historic Main Street Victorian and Colonial district, mid-century inland housing, and waterfront contemporary homes with views of Great South Bay. We quote three very different types of gutter work depending on which pocket of the town we're in.
Local housing stock
Mix of historic Victorian and Colonial near the bay, 1960s capes inland, waterfront contemporaries on the canals.
Waterfront homes deal with salt air (steel or copper recommended). The Victorian district often needs half-round copper for architectural correctness. Inland capes and ranches are standard aluminum seamless work. The common thread: Bay Shore's heavy summer thunderstorm runoff means we often upsize to 6" gutters and 3x4 downspouts.
Landmarks nearby: Bay Shore Marina, Main Street historic district, Fire Island ferry terminals. We’ve worked throughout Bay Shore— if you’re near any of these, there’s a good chance we’ve installed on your block already.

Services available in Bay Shore
Recent jobs in Bay Shore & nearby
A slice of what we’ve been working on in Bay Shore and neighboring Brightwaters, West Islip, Islip, Babylon.
Leak at the front corner miter after an ice dam. Cut out the bad section, formed a new corner on-site, sealed and re-hung. In and out in 2 hours.
175ft of 6-inch seamless on a waterfront property with heavy rain exposure. Larger downspouts, kickout flashing at all wall intersections.
Formed 182 linear feet of 6-inch white aluminum K-style seamless gutters on-site for a 2-story colonial. Hidden hangers every 24 inches, 3x4 downspouts, splash blocks.
Hand-bagged debris from 145ft of gutters on a Cape Cod, flow-tested each downspout, snaked one clogged drop. Sent homeowner before/after photos same day.
Installed stainless micromesh guards on 120ft of existing K-style gutters for a Tudor home. Homeowner had three LeafFilter quotes at 3x our price.
Tore off 40-year-old steel gutters, wrapped fascia with white aluminum coil, installed 160ft of new 5-inch seamless. Fixed pitch that was causing overflow by the front door.
Re-hung 28ft of sagging gutter pulling off the fascia, replaced 12 hidden hangers, sealed two corner miters. Same-day fix, $220.
Half-round solid copper gutters with round copper downspouts on a 1920s Tudor. Soldered seams. Homeowner wanted the patina — no sealer.
What Bay Shore homeowners say
“Danny's crew installed seamless gutters on our colonial. Formed on-site. 2 years later, zero leaks. Highly recommend.”
“Called Tuesday for cleaning, they were out Friday. Fully insured, sent before/after photos. Exactly what you want.”
“LI Gutter was the only contractor who explained micromesh vs reverse-curve without trying to upsell LeafFilter at 3x.”
Nearby towns we serve
Bay Shore FAQ
Still wondering about something specific to your home? Call (516) 529-6634.
(516) 529-6634Free quote in one visit
Pick up the phone or send us the details. We'll respond same-day, Monday through Saturday.